Loading...
 
 Note
This page is to document "what Tiki should do". For feature documentation (what Tiki does), please see corresponding page on doc site
Add your ideas on wiki pages, tracker items, poll, etc Type of page ยป  Feature page

Comment

Related: Karma

Other wishes:

  • 9x: can't use plugin helper when posting a comment. Click question mark and try to use the CODE plugin
  • 9x: can't edit comments anymore (was possible in previous versions of Tiki)
    • Was re-added later
  • tiki-user_information.php is missing tracker comments
  • WYSIWYCA for Karma related things (filters, etc.)
  • New comments admin panel done in Tiki6
  • Trunk 2009-10-12: comment filtering: Style is always threaded
  • Trunk 2009-10-12: comment filtering: Add a threshold to show (now hard coded to 10)
  • Trunk 2010-09-08: for anon comments, it asks email, but it should specify that this email will not be made public
    • Could be nice to tie this into watch - planned for Tiki7
  • Trunk 2010-09-08: If I make a comment on a page "Hello", after saving I am sent to tiki-index.php#comments instead of tiki-Hello#comments (so I can mail the URL to a friend)
  • tiki-list_comments.php is missing tracker comments (9.0)
  • users/admins can't edit comments

Open

RatingSubjectSubmitted byImportanceEasy to solve?PriorityCategoryVolunteered to solveLastModifComments
(0) Illogical paginationhman8864
  • Dogfood on a *.tiki.org site
  • Consistency
2021-06-063
hman-11 Jun 21
(0) Post new comment gives "Warning: Invalid argument supplied for foreach" tiki 8.2Lusserall510 easy50
  • Error
2012-04-182
marclaporte-18 Apr 12
(0) The ">" character is double-parsed in "Multiple new comments, including" of SYLV moduleluciash d' being ๐Ÿง™10 easy50
  • Consistency
2016-04-110
(0) Add IP to syslog and/or action log when anons (at least) add content (for spam protection)Xavier de Pedro6848
  • Usability
  • Feature request
  • Less than 30-minutes fix
2010-01-140
(0) Comments dont show up when comments_archive is set9 high45
  • Error
2011-08-242
tortugamarina-27 Jan 13
(0) Editing a comment for a trackeritem does not update the comment using codemirrorWolfgangA6742
  • Error
2015-02-080
(0) 'Display Post new comment form by default' pref brokenXavier de Pedro5840
  • Usability
  • Regression
2019-10-244
xavi-24 Oct 19
(0) Admin comments does not parse comments even if parsing enabledPhilippe Cloutier1 low44
  • Regression
2013-11-190
(0) Make tracker comments searchablemnl735
  • Usability
  • Consistency
2010-02-231
marclaporte-28 Apr 12
(0) Bug: Posting as anonymous while logged in throws error735
  • Error
2011-08-170
(0) 13.x dev.tiki.org Stray "Add Comment" button all the way at the bottom of the pageMarc Laporte5735
  • Usability
  • Regression
2014-07-280
(0) Comments are cachedJean-Marc Libs7535
  • Bug
2019-05-280
(0) dev.tiki.org 13.x threading on tracker comments is not ergonomicMarc Laporte4832
  • Usability
  • Regression
2014-08-300
(0) Disappering comments in pageChristophe630
  • Error
2010-05-190
(0) No Indentation of Forum Replies or Wiki Page Comments using Theme TheNews v6.7EmmArrBee630
  • Usability
2012-06-150
(0) Certain comments partially hidden (Google Chrome)Philippe Cloutier630
  • Bug
2018-03-050
(0) Unable to reply or post to comments to tracker items with Chromium or SeaMonkey browsers (fine with Firefox)Xavier de Pedro6530
  • Error
  • Dogfood on a *.tiki.org site
  • Regression
2018-09-230
(0) System error when attempting to enable blog comments on a blog created by a profileXavier de Pedro7428
  • Error
  • Conflict of two features (each works well independently)
2017-08-050
(0) QUOTE plugin in comments, replyto automatic parameter, missing default attributepmorenogarcia525
  • Usability
  • Patch
2009-09-071
drsassafras-26 Feb 20
(0) If more than 10 comments, not possible to set (change) comment filterMarc Laporte525
  • Regression
2009-12-270
(0) Comments EditScott M. Sanders525
  • Feature request
2011-05-190
(0) Eval error in event debug console in IEluciash d' being ๐Ÿง™25
  • Error
2015-02-180
(1) 14.x: wrong comments count displayed (maybe it shows # of edits, and not # of comments?)Xavier de Pedro5525
  • Error
2015-04-278
manivannans-04 May 15
(0) Clicking a file link in a diff view in comment produces garbled dataG.525
  • Usability
  • Bug
2019-07-240
(0) tracker comment editwiki_toolbar is not turned off even if section_comments_parse is disabledGergely5525
  • Bug
2020-02-160
(0) Slides in 21.x: Section about wiki page comments wrongly placed on top of all slide titlesXavier de Pedro5525
  • Usability
  • Regression
  • Conflict of two features (each works well independently)
2020-04-060
(0) Assign the object/item name it is related to a comment (instead of untitled)Bernard Sfez / Tiki Specialist5525
  • Feature request
  • Dogfood on a *.tiki.org site
2020-06-160
(0) Comment are not allowed but still posted (dev)Bernard Sfez / Tiki Specialist5525
  • Dogfood on a *.tiki.org site
2020-10-090
(0) Feature to discuss wiki pages in forums sends a notification email (group watches) each time the use clicks at the button 'Start discussion' (even if the discussion and thread was already started by someone else previously)Xavier de Pedro4624
  • Error
  • Conflict of two features (each works well independently)
  • Less than 30-minutes fix
2016-11-300
(0) Setting Admin Home>Comments>Comments below wiki pages>Display by default does not workpswzyu420
  • Usability
2011-12-160
(0) Adding a new comment takes you to previous one afterwardsJonny Bradley2918
  • Usability
2019-10-191
luci-23 Oct 19
(0) BACKLINKS includes CommentsEmmArrBee315
  • Error
2014-05-061
EmmArrBee-06 May 14
(0) ADD AUTOCOMPLETION IN TIKI OF USERS IN COMMENTS WHEN THERE'S "@" SYMBOLSamy mwamba4312
  • Developer Training
2018-10-241
drsassafras-26 Feb 20
(0) thresold...Daniel Germer210
  • Consistency
2009-04-240

Pending

RatingSubjectSubmitted byImportanceEasy to solve?PriorityCategoryVolunteered to solveLastModifComments
(1) Screencasts in comments: no longer showingMarc Laporte10 high990
  • Regression
manivannans2014-01-103
xavidp-01 Dec 13
(0) Add a select box to monitor each own's forum post, comments or tracker submission or wiki page at post timeXavi (as xavidp - admin)10 high880
  • Usability
  • Feature request
  • Dogfood on a *.tiki.org site
Nelson Ko2013-11-017
drsassafras-26 Feb 20
(0) Username can't have space in it for messageing system BugAndriy Podanenko945
  • Error
  • Usability
sylvieg2013-06-050
(0) Comments to individual images in the image galleryMarc Laporte735
  • Feature request
2008-02-031
morrighu-23 Apr 08
(0) comments disapper and can't be recoveredMoritz Haag735
  • Error
2005-10-090
(0) Wiki syntax doesn't work in Tracker commentsmarbux630
  • Usability
  • Dogfood on a *.tiki.org site
2008-02-041
marclaporte-10 Jul 07
(0) Include option to separate voting on forums from karma or score systemXavi (as xavidp - admin)630
  • Feature request
2008-02-031
djrakun-09 Feb 09
(0) Blog comment notificationrpg25
  • Feature request
rpg2007-07-076
coflynn-16 Aug 11
(0) Display external wikis and abbreviations in editormarbux25
  • Usability
marbux2005-11-080
(0) Comments don't show if 'Display comments form by default' is enableddadio5525
  • Usability
  • Regression
  • Developer Training
2013-10-280
(0) Comments to Image Galleries cause failure in mod-since_last_visit_new.php causing site crashBreakingPaint25
  • Error
2011-07-051
Chealer9-05 Jul 11
(0) Comment options - Reply, Edit, Delete, Archive - disappear when clicked ontripspec5525
  • Usability
2017-02-127
jonnybradley-12 Feb 17
(0) Forum & comment threading: make optional and plain (not threaded) by defaultMarc Laporte315
  • Feature request
nyloth2007-07-091
BillMac-07 Dec 07
(0) Calendar items: adding a commentMarc Laporte315
  • Feature request
2007-07-100
(0) When clicking a link to answer (re) a comment (at least on blog), the comment section colaps.KaiiaK315
  • Usability
2008-08-200
(0) Comments to individual files in file galleryMarc Laporte210
  • Feature request
sylvieg2007-01-050

Closed

RatingSubjectSubmitted byImportanceEasy to solve?PriorityCategoryVolunteered to solveLastModifComments
(0) Ip logging in many table too short for IPv6canelli9 high10 easy90
  • Feature request
  • Less than 30-minutes fix
2012-08-103
marclaporte-10 Aug 12
(0) cannot view/add/edit tracker commentsGergely810 easy80
  • Regression
2020-01-266
Gergely-16 Jun 19
(0) Cannot Reply to a Comment on Wiki pagepsue9 high872
  • Error
  • Conflict of two features (each works well independently)
  • Less than 30-minutes fix
2010-01-141
marclaporte-27 Dec 09
(0) nofollow on hyperlinksMarc Laporte8864
  • Feature request
  • Less than 30-minutes fix
2010-08-238
marclaporte-23 Aug 10
(1) 12.x: content of tracker comments tab is not shown! (in dev.t.o)Xavier de Pedro9763
  • Error
  • Community projects
  • Regression
  • Less than 30-minutes fix
2014-07-131
xavi-13 Jul 14
(0) Since your last visit "Multiple new comments, including" links should show the Tracker "Comments" tabluciash d' being ๐Ÿง™610 easy60
  • Usability
luciash d' being ๐Ÿง™2013-08-273
pascalstjean-26 Aug 13
(0) Do not display [comment] link, when no perm to post comments and no comments posted yetluciash d' being ๐Ÿง™8756
  • Usability
  • Dogfood on a *.tiki.org site
  • Less than 30-minutes fix
2010-01-141
kimberlyf-14 Jan 10
(1) Tracker Comments tab doesn't show number in parenthesis as Attachments doluciash d' being ๐Ÿง™10 easy50
  • Consistency
luciash d' being ๐Ÿง™2014-09-190
(0) Saving a comment using the Save and Comment button on the whishlist creates 2 identical commentsBernard Sfez / Tiki Specialist7749
  • Dogfood on a *.tiki.org site
  • Regression
  • Conflict of two features (each works well independently)
  • Bug
2021-05-194
luci-23 Apr 21
(0) Numbered ol list does not display numbers in comments hereluciash d' being ๐Ÿง™945
  • Usability
  • Dogfood on a *.tiki.org site
  • Regression
  • Less than 30-minutes fix
Gary Cunningham-Lee2015-02-193
luci-18 Feb 15
(1) Wrong feedback to comment poster when Comments Moderation is on and post is not shownXavier de Pedro6742
  • Error
  • Usability
2014-07-254
jonnybradley-21 Jul 14
(0) Wiki comments are not counted like in 1.8 (now only top level)Marc Laporte840
  • Error
luciash d' being ๐Ÿง™2005-04-290
(0) Spam filtering: Bad Behavior or Mollom or Akismet, Defensio or TypePad AntiSpamMarc Laporte840
  • Feature request
  • Dogfood on a *.tiki.org site
2011-10-030
(0) Data corruption in Tiki bug tracker commentsArild Berg8540
  • Release Blocker
2013-11-017
arild-01 Nov 13
(0) Only show "10/20/30/All" (drop-down) comments filter if number of comments is > 10Marc Laporte840
  • Usability
  • Feature request
sylvieg2007-12-310
(0) Comments to tracker items can't be posted when codemirror is onXavier de Pedro6636
  • Usability
  • Dogfood on a *.tiki.org site
  • Regression
2016-12-080
(0) Comments: Do not show Style/Sort/Threshold/Search unless enough comments Marc Laporte735
  • Usability
  • Dogfood on a *.tiki.org site
2013-06-050
(0) link_cache creates SQL errormrisch735
  • Error
  • Regression
Louis-Philippe Huberdeau2009-10-110
(1) 5x-16.x: tracker comments should allow self-subscribe option for poster, like in forum posts or page commentsXavier de Pedro7535
  • Usability
  • Support request
  • Dogfood on a *.tiki.org site
2016-10-144
kroky6-18 Oct 16
(0) No indentation of Forum Replies and Comments - Theme TheNews TW v6.7EmmArrBee735
  • Usability
2012-06-150
(1) 12.x: can't post comments if codemirror is on (it says 'Content is empty')Xavier de Pedro7535
  • Error
  • Usability
  • Regression
2014-07-130
(0) 13.x: Comments can't be posted in some pages of a FeaturedProfileXavier de Pedro7535
  • Community projects
  • Regression
  • Consistency
2014-07-101
gezza-09 Jul 14
(2) bug in moving a forum threadolinuxx735
  • Error
  • Usability
  • Support request
  • Regression
2016-03-033
olinuxx-02 Mar 16
(0) Cannot add a comment to a wiki page, if the wikipage uses a namespaceWolfgangA735
  • Release Blocker
wolfganga2015-01-250
(0) My first post of the day in the Tiki forum is never savedBernard Sfez / Tiki Specialist7535
  • Dogfood on a *.tiki.org site
  • Regression
2020-03-120
(1) 14.x: Comments can't be posted nor edited when codemirror is switched on (or 'disabled but switchable')Xavier de Pedro8432
  • Usability
Jonny Bradley2015-04-101
koth-23 Aug 14
(0) voting on forum post comments shown & working when rating per forum not selectedXavi (as xavidp - admin)630
  • Error
Marc Laporte2009-04-101
xavidp-05 Jan 07
(0) Page comments fail when page name contains a commaJean-Marc Libs630
  • Regression
Jonny Bradley2015-03-090
(2) Anonymous comment posters do no receive email notification of replies to their comments, even if they leave their email address as indicated.Xavier de Pedro7428
  • Feature request
2016-10-131
xavi-28 Jun 16
(1) 12.0: First edit of a Tracker item comment is LOST (!); second attempt is saved successfully, it seems. Reproduced twice in dev.t.o/t5Xavier de Pedro9327
  • Dogfood on a *.tiki.org site
  • Regression
Jonny Bradley2014-02-044
jonnybradley-04 Feb 14
(0) Forums: move topic to another forum id (feature already exists)Marc Laporte525
  • Feature request
Mike2007-11-290
(0) Error in tiki-list_comments.php - no comments on listmrisch525
  • Error
2008-01-011
nkoth-01 Jan 08
(0) Comments that must be approved before being postedMarc Laporte525
  • Feature request
nyloth2008-10-061
mrisch-04 Jun 08
(0) Comzone cookie not getting updatedspace_egd525
  • Consistency
2020-02-261
drsassafras-26 Feb 20
(0) Last comments for trackers : module neededMarc Laporte525
  • Feature request
  • Dogfood on a *.tiki.org site
Luis Henrique Fagundes2007-08-131
fmathias-20 Jan 06
(0) Post comment catgory permissions are ignored252011-10-080
(0) Threaded comments second level not showingNelson Ko25
  • Release Blocker
2014-06-190
(0) Comments: anonymous editors must input anti-bot code:Marc Laporte525
  • Feature request
sylvieg2007-12-256
mrisch-25 Jun 08
(0) Improve comments UX (why 4 times the word comment?)Marc Laporte25
  • Feature request
2018-07-061
chibaguy-06 Jul 18
(0) Save and Comment and Save Returning to Item List doesn't work with SafariBernard Sfez / Tiki Specialist5525
  • Regression
2021-07-042
Bsfez-15 Mar 20
(0) 'Comments' on dev.tiki.org not turned onMike Finko5525
  • Usability
2020-11-121
mikeua-12 Nov 20
(0) text annotations (select a snippet, and add a signed/dated text note)Marc Laporte7321
  • Feature request
  • Dogfood on a *.tiki.org site
Marc Laporte2013-11-031
frankb-26 Jan 11
(0) Module since_last_visit_new shows unapproved commentsjoerg420
  • Usability
  • Consistency
  • Conflict of two features (each works well independently)
Philippe Cloutier2011-01-040
(0) Comment box below wiki page opens too small the first timemheller420
  • Regression
2011-02-010
(0) enhancing spam fight and protection: from multiple comments to banning multiple ips with minimum clicksXavier de Pedro420
  • Feature request
Jean-Marc Libs2011-09-261
Jyhem-07 Sep 11
(0) Since your last visit: clicking link takes me to the wrong commentMarc Laporte3618
  • Usability
Jonny Bradley2015-05-122
manivannans-12 May 15
(0)