Wrong feedback to comment poster when Comments Moderation is on and post is not shown
- Status
- Closed
- Subject
- Wrong feedback to comment poster when Comments Moderation is on and post is not shown
- Version
- 12.x
13.x - Category
- Error
- Usability
- Feature
- Comment
Edit interface (UI)
Spam protection (Anti-bot CAPTCHA) - Resolution status
- Fixed or Solved
- Submitted by
- Xavier de Pedro
- Lastmod by
- Xavier de Pedro
- Rating
- Description
Missing (12.x) or wrong (13.x) feedback to comment poster when Comments Moderation is on and post is not shown
However, in the show.t.o instance for 12.x, I couldn't get the same behavior I saw a few weeks in a 12.x in localhost.
Current issues reproduced in the show.t.o 12.x instance:
Adding a comment as anon to the homepage (with comments moderation enabled):
http://xavi-9794-5310.show.tikiwiki.org/tiki-index.phpCopy to clipboardNotice: Array to string conversion in /var/www/xavi-9794-5310/vendor/bombayworks/zendframework1/library/Zend/Filter/Alnum.php on line 144Copy to clipboardYour comment was posted. No object information provided.
In 13.x I saw the same output (without the initial array notice):Copy to clipboardYour comment was posted. No object information provided.
This seems to be an error message:No object information provided
And "Your comment was posted." is a missleading information, since the comment is not visible yet (until moderation happens). So a better message could be shown in this case, something like:"Your comment was posted but is pending moderation, and until approval, it will not be shown"
When viewing the page again, it says:
"There are no comments at this time."when you would expect to see something like:
"There are some comments hidden pending moderation"
And last, as registered users, there is no feedback of what happens in that tiki site that their comments are gone after clicking at "post".- Solution
Fixed the case for anonymous users posting with comment moderation enabled, in r51991 (13.x) and r51992 (12.x)
Still pending some way to do an equivalent fix for registered users. They currently get no feedback of what happens in that tiki site that their comments are gone after clicking at "post".
fixed by jonnyb in r52052 & r52054 in 13.x, and backported to 12.x in r52114 . Thanks jonnyb
- Importance
- 6
- Easy to solve?
- 7
- Priority
- 42
- Demonstrate Bug on Tiki 19+
-
This bug has been demonstrated on show2.tiki.org
Please demonstrate your bug on show2.tiki.org
Show.tiki.org is not configured properlyThe public/private keys configured to connect to show2.tiki.org were not accepted. Please make sure you are using RSA keys. Thanks.
- Demonstrate Bug (older Tiki versions)
-
This bug has been demonstrated on show.tikiwiki.org
Please demonstrate your bug on show.tikiwiki.org
Show.tiki.org is not configured properlyThe public/private keys configured to connect to show.tikiwiki.org were not accepted. Please make sure you are using RSA keys. Thanks.
- Ticket ID
- 5310
- Created
- Thursday 10 July, 2014 19:31:51 UTC
by Xavier de Pedro - LastModif
- Friday 25 July, 2014 19:56:29 UTC