Category: H5P

Hi,

I have upgraded to tiki 24 and I am trying to create a interactive video with H5P in file gallery, but get stuck on creating screen.

{img fileId="1793" thumb="box"}

In a new installation of branch 21.2, I get the error "H5P directory is not writable: storage/public/h5p". This is on a Windows laptop in a WAMP stack. After I manually make the storage/public/h5p directory, then the error no longer displays. I'm not sure if this happens only on Windows installations.

After uploading .h5p files to unlock the different content types, some of the creation wizards do not display all of the necessary information, preventing the creation of the new content. I've compiled a list of the different content types and how functional the editor is with each:

✅ Accordion - Fully functional
? Agamotto - Only an option for a title
✅ Arithmetic Quiz - Fully functional
✅ Audio Recorder - Fully functional
? Chart - Partially functional - bar/slice color and text color cannot be set
❌ ~np~Collage - Only the text string '[field:group:collage:collage]' gets displayed~/np~
✅ Column - Appears to be fully functional
❌ ~np~Course Presentation - Only the text string '[field:group:coursepresentation:presentation]' gets displayed, as well as behavior and text overrides.~/np~
? Dialog Cards - Only some text boxes, no entries for changing/adding cards
? Documentation Tool - Only an option for a title
❌ ~np~Drag and Drop - Shows the text string '[field:group:wizard:question]', an empty collapse, and a collapse for text overrides~/np~
? Drag the Words - Functional, but has an empty collapse after the other content
? Fill in the Blanks - Functional, but has an empty collapse after the other content
❌ ~np~Find Multiple Hotspots - Just the text string '[field:group:wizard:imageMultipleHotspotQuestion]' gets displayed~/np~
❌ ~np~Find the Hotspot - Just the text string '[field:group:wizard:imageHotspotQuestion]' and a dropdown for text overrides get displayed~/np~
? Flashcards - Only a textbox for 'Task description' gets displayed
✅ Guess the Answer - Fully functional
❔ Iframe Embedder - Does not appear to get parsed by Tiki, which is probably for the best.
❌ ~np~Image Hotspots - Some inputs get displayed, but a number are only text, such as '[field:text:colorSelector:color]' and '[field:group:imageCoordinateSelector:position]'~/np~
? Image Juxtaposition - Mostly functional. When editing an image, error message comes up indicating 'Invalid format'.
✅ Image Sequencing - Fully functional
? ~np~Image Slider - Mostly functional, but appears to not parse one input, '[field:group:showWhen:aspectRatio]'~/np~
❌ ~np~Impressive Presentation - Only displays '[field:group:impressPresentationEditor:viewsGroup]', but it appears this content type is still in alpha~/np~
❌ ~np~Interactive Video - Only displays '[field:group:wizard:interactiveVideo]', behavioral settings, and text overrides. From my experience in other H5P editors, this input has something akin to tabs.~/np~
? Mark the Words - Appears functional, but has empty collapse after other inputs
❌ Memory Game - Displays nothing at all.
? Multiple Choice - Appears fully functional, but has blank collapse after other inputs
? ~np~Personality Quiz - Mostly functional, but has missing inputs '[field:text:colorSelector:buttonColor] and '[field:text:colorSelector:progressbarColor]'~/np~
❔ Questionnaire - Not parsed by tiki
? Quiz (Question Set) - No inputs for editing/adding questions, but everything else seemed functional
✅ Single Choice Set - Fully functional
Speak the Words - Not tested (requires browser with speech recognition)
Speak the Words Set - Not tested (requires browser with speech recognition)
✅ Summary - Fully functional
✅ Timeline - Fully functional
? ~np~True/False Question - No option to select correct answer, '[field:select:radioGroup:correct]'~/np~
✅ Twitter User Feed - Fully functional
---
''Legend:''
✅ Fully functional
? Partially working/partially broken
❌ Completely Unusable
❔ Unclear

when testing how to use ((h5p)) in Tiki, I saw this message several times when setting up the whole process:

-+H5P directory is not writable: storage/public/h5p+-

The first times, the folder hadn't been created. (sorry I tested many things, and I didn't record - nor recall - all the steps I did).
The last time I saw that message, the folder had been created indeed by Tiki, and with permissions for apache to write in it. So this last time might have been a false positive error message.

Reproduced in a show2.t.o, while showing also many other error messages combined with success messages (there is room for improvements in usability, I reckon):
http://xavi-9794-7160.show2.tikiwiki.org/tiki-ajax_services.php?controller=h5p&action=embed&fileId=1
u: admin
p: 12345

{img fileId="1317" thumb="box"}

^
Error

H5P directory is not writable: storage/public/h5p

Success

Your site was successfully registered with the H5P Hub.

Success

Library cache was successfully updated!

Error

The system was unable to install the Drag N Bar component from the package, it requires a newer version of the H5P plugin. This site is currently running version Drag N Bar, whereas the required version is Drag N Bar or higher. You should consider upgrading and then try again. (code=api-version-unsupported)

Error

The system was unable to install the Drag and Drop component from the package, it requires a newer version of the H5P plugin. This site is currently running version Drag and Drop, whereas the required version is Drag and Drop or higher. You should consider upgrading and then try again. (code=api-version-unsupported)

Error

The system was unable to install the Drag Question Editor component from the package, it requires a newer version of the H5P plugin. This site is currently running version Drag Question Editor, whereas the required version is Drag Question Editor or higher. You should consider upgrading and then try again. (code=api-version-unsupported)

Error

The system was unable to install the H5PEditor.Wizard component from the package, it requires a newer version of the H5P plugin. This site is currently running version H5PEditor.Wizard, whereas the required version is H5PEditor.Wizard or higher. You should consider upgrading and then try again. (code=api-version-unsupported)

Success

Added 11 new H5P libraries.

Error

Click here to rebuild index
^

After installation of H5P, some H5P objects are not installable. Some others run correctly.

For instance : "Image Hotspots" can't be installed with the error message : "Validating h5p package failed."

Created in h5p.org site, then uploaded in Tiki, such a file can't run in Tiki 20.
Error message : "H5P Plugin: Cannot find H5P content with fileId: 12."
Found in PHP errors : "No AJAX service matches request parameters (404)"

Searching in H5P.org, it seems that our php library for this plugin needs an update.

Tested with a fresh installation 20.1 on xampp 7.3.9 AND demo.tiki.org/20x

__Please mind that the described H5P related bug occurs whilst not using H5P, but using the file gallery when H5P is activated. Deactivating H5P makes the bug disappear.__

# Upgraded existing Tiki 19 to Tiki 21.x (future, currently trunk) at 16 Oct 2019.
+
# Activated H5P
## created an extra new file gallery for H5P
## did not (yet) set ''Site Key'' and ''H5P UUID'', as I do not yet heard about them
## did not yet upload any H5P files and not yet try to use H5P in this Tiki instance
## the folder in tikiroot ''storage/public/h5p'' is existing, likely created automatically during upgrade
+
# When I got to the preferences of an arbitrary file in an arbitrary existing file gallery, maybe change some preference like editing the description or even do no change at all and then I save this file, two things happen:
## The file is saved/updated correctly (ex: description updated
## Tiki does __not__ refer back to the file gallery, but instead to a ''WSOD'' blank page with an error message. I have to manually alter the url in the browsers address line or to use the browsers back button to get back to my Tiki.

__This is the error message:__

{CODE()}
Parse error: syntax error, unexpected ')' in /www/htdocs/Path-To-Tikiroot/lib/core/H5P/H5PTiki.php on line 947
{CODE}

Creating the first H5P file is successful, but when you try to create additional H5P files, it fails.

{img fileId="1697" thumb="box"}

In my 19.2 (svn) it appears the H5P application is working beautifully, at first. I can initiate an application, edit it, upload images to the application, but when it comes time to save the application and display it, the images do not appear. If I go back to the application and edit it, the images have dissappeared.
--This may be unique to my own installation of tiki, I will create a show instance here, and see if it is only my installation, or if it truly is a bug.-- I reproduced it on my own Tiki. {sign user="luci" datetime="2019-02-20T08:43:02+00:00"}

If you would like to see what I am seeing on my own test installation, you can go to --http://tpwtestuser.com/tikisvn/HomePage--

updated link: https://tiki22.tpwtestuser.com/tiki-index.php
User: admin
Pass: 12345

I got a weird message form ((doc:PluginH5P)) in tiki saying that the fileId number of the h5p file I uploaded to Tiki was wrong: "H5P Plugin: Cannot find H5P content with fileId: 770.", and fileId 770 is the fileId number of that brand new h5p file I uploaded to the file gal.

Reindexing didn't help.

Using H5P Collage, when the file is inserted into page using for example:

{CODE(theme="default")}{h5p fileId="32"}{CODE}

The collage looks fine, but when the page is cached, the images fly out of the constrained area and convert to full size images.

Please see show instance.