Loading...
 
Skip to main content

12.0: First edit of a Tracker item comment is LOST (!); second attempt is saved successfully, it seems. Reproduced twice in dev.t.o/t5

  • Tracker item actions
Trackers
Items
Status
Closed
Subject
12.0: First edit of a Tracker item comment is LOST (!); second attempt is saved successfully, it seems. Reproduced twice in dev.t.o/t5
Version
12.x
12.x Regression
Category
  • Regression
  • Dogfood on a *.tiki.org site
Feature
Comment
Edit interface (UI)
Trackers
Resolution status
Fixed or Solved
Submitted by
Xavier de Pedro
Volunteered to solve
Jonny Bradley
Lastmod by
Xavier de Pedro
Rating
(1)
Related-to
Description

After 12.0 has been released (using r48863 in dev.t.o): First edit of a Tracker item comment is LOST (!); second attempt is saved successfully, it seems.

Reproduced twice in http://dev.tiki.org/tiki-view_tracker_item.php?itemId=5019&cookietab=2

  • I edited the comment entitled "Licensing issues have NOT been resolved yet, some code needs to be rewritten":
    http://dev.tiki.org/tiki-comment-edit?type=trackeritem&objectId=5019&threadId=3572

  • I added at the begining this content (the one surrounded by QUOTE tags):
    Copy to clipboard
    {QUOTE()}
Now that licensing issues have been resolved, please move to the main code base.
{QUOTE}

    I clicked at SAVE. Tiki refreshed the page as usual as if the comment was saved, but the content was not updated. Visiting again the page confirmed that the edition was not saved. Doing a second edition, saved that change successfully.


And I reproduced the same issue a few minutes later with another comment to the same tracker item:

  • I edited the comment entitled "See r48864 from mods":
    http://dev.tiki.org/tiki-comment-edit?type=trackeritem&objectId=5019&threadId=3574

  • Changed "NEED REWRITING" with "NEEDS REWRITING", clicked at SAVE. Tiki refreshed the page as usual as if the comment was saved, but the content was not updated. Visiting again the page confirmed that the edition was not saved. Doing a second edition, saved that change successfully.

I wonder whether this might be considered a Blocker... I don't tag it as such myself, but feel free to add if you consider that it deserve that category also (unsure myself).

Apparently, a duplicate of http://dev.tiki.org/item5007
(even if the title there was missleading to me)

Still reproduced here in dev.t.o, with a version from 20 January, 2014 16:44:28 CET- REV 49469.

I removed the "duplicated" tag, since the other item is solved ( http://dev.tiki.org/item5007 ), but not this one.

Solution

r49709?

Fixed, thanks jonnyb

Importance
9
Easy to solve?
3
Priority
27
Demonstrate Bug on Tiki 19+
Demonstrate Bug (older Tiki versions)
Ticket ID
5021
Created
Sunday 01 December, 2013 10:36:08 UTC
by Xavier de Pedro
LastModif
Tuesday 04 February, 2014 18:35:46 UTC


Show PHP error messages