Related: Karma

Other wishes:

  • 9x: can't use plugin helper when posting a comment. Click question mark and try to use the CODE plugin
  • 9x: can't edit comments anymore (was possible in previous versions of Tiki)
    • Was re-added later
  • tiki-user_information.php is missing tracker comments
  • WYSIWYCA for Karma related things (filters, etc.)
  • New comments admin panel done in Tiki6
  • Trunk 2009-10-12: comment filtering: Style is always threaded
  • Trunk 2009-10-12: comment filtering: Add a threshold to show (now hard coded to 10)
  • Trunk 2010-09-08: for anon comments, it asks email, but it should specify that this email will not be made public
    • Could be nice to tie this into watch - planned for Tiki7
  • Trunk 2010-09-08: If I make a comment on a page "Hello", after saving I am sent to tiki-index.php#comments instead of tiki-Hello#comments (so I can mail the URL to a friend)
  • tiki-list_comments.php is missing tracker comments (9.0)
  • users/admins can't edit comments

Open

RatingSubject Submitted byImportanceEasy to solve?PriorityCategoryVolunteered to solveCreatedLastModifComments
(0) 13.x dev.tiki.org Stray "Add Comment" button all the way at the bottom of the pageMarc Laporte5735
  • Usability
  • Regression
2014-07-282014-07-280
(1) 14.x: wrong comments count displayed (maybe it shows # of edits, and not # of comments?)Xavier de Pedro5525
  • Error
2015-04-102015-04-278
manivannans-04 May 15
(0) Add IP to syslog and/or action log when anons (at least) add content (for spam protection)Xavier de Pedro6848
  • Usability
  • Feature request
  • Less than 30-minutes fix
2010-01-142010-01-140
(0) Adding a new comment takes you to previous one afterwardsJonny Bradley2918
  • Usability
2019-10-192019-10-191
luci-23 Oct 19
(0) Admin comments does not parse comments even if parsing enabledPhilippe Cloutier1 low44
  • Regression
2009-10-282013-11-190
(0) BACKLINKS includes CommentsEmmArrBee315
  • Error
2014-05-062014-05-061
EmmArrBee-06 May 14
(0) Bug: Posting as anonymous while logged in throws error735
  • Error
2011-08-172011-08-170
(0) Calendar items: adding a commentMarc Laporte315
  • Feature request
2007-06-032021-10-251
Bsfez-25 Oct 21
(0) Certain comments partially hidden (Google Chrome)Philippe Cloutier630
  • Bug
2018-03-052018-03-050
(0) Clicking a file link in a diff view in comment produces garbled dataG.525
  • Usability
  • Bug
2019-07-232019-07-240
(0) Comments are cachedJean-Marc Libs7535
  • Bug
2019-05-282019-05-280
(0) Comments dont show up when comments_archive is set9 high45
  • Error
2011-08-242011-08-242
tortugamarina-27 Jan 13
(0) Comments EditScott M. Sanders525
  • Feature request
2011-05-192011-05-190
(0) Comments, Buttons, User interface; Improving the user interfaceBernard Sfez / Tiki Specialist3515
  • Feature request
2022-12-112022-12-110
(0) Comments; Comments are expecting a title and most don't haveBernard Sfez / Tiki Specialist5525
  • Feature request
  • Dogfood on a *.tiki.org site
2020-06-162022-12-060
(0) Dev.t.o, Comments, user tag; Behaviour for the user tag (at-bsfez) has changed and look brokenBernard Sfez / Tiki Specialist7535
  • Dogfood on a *.tiki.org site
  • Regression
2022-03-012022-03-010
(0) dev.tiki.org 13.x threading on tracker comments is not ergonomicMarc Laporte4832
  • Usability
  • Regression
2014-08-302014-08-300
(0) Disappering comments in pageChristophe630
  • Error
2010-05-192010-05-190
(0) Editing a comment for a trackeritem does not update the comment using codemirrorWolfgangA6742
  • Error
2015-02-082015-02-080
(0) Empty comments shouldn't be possible or they shouldn't be displayed in Since your last visitBernard Sfez / Tiki Specialist5525
  • Dogfood on a *.tiki.org site
  • Conflict of two features (each works well independently)
  • Developer Training
  • Easy for Newbie Dev
2021-11-152021-11-150
  • «
  • 1 (current)
  • 2

Pending

RatingSubjectSubmitted byImportanceEasy to solve?PriorityCategoryVolunteered to solveCreatedLastModifComments
(1) Screencasts in comments: no longer showingMarc Laporte10 high990
  • Regression
manivannans2013-11-292014-01-103
xavidp-01 Dec 13
(0) Slides in 21.x: Section about wiki page comments wrongly placed on top of all slide titlesXavier de Pedro5735
  • Usability
  • Regression
  • Conflict of two features (each works well independently)
  • Developer Training
  • Easy for Newbie Dev
2020-04-042022-01-220
(0) Username can't have space in it for messageing system BugAndriy Podanenko5525
  • Error
  • Usability
  • Feature request
sylvieg2005-06-242021-09-294
Jyhem-29 Sep 21
(0) Blog comment notificationrpg25
  • Feature request
rpg2007-07-072007-07-076
coflynn-16 Aug 11
(0) Comments don't show if 'Display comments form by default' is enableddadio5525
  • Usability
  • Regression
  • Developer Training
2013-06-272013-10-280
(0) Comment options - Reply, Edit, Delete, Archive - disappear when clicked ontripspec5525
  • Usability
2017-02-102017-02-127
jonnybradley-12 Feb 17
(0) When clicking a link to answer (re) a comment (at least on blog), the comment section colaps.KaiiaK315
  • Usability
2008-08-202008-08-200

Closed

RatingSubjectSubmitted byImportanceEasy to solve? PriorityCategoryVolunteered to solveCreatedLastModifComments
(0) Wiki comments are not counted like in 1.8 (now only top level)Marc Laporte840
  • Error
luciash d' being 🧙2005-04-262005-04-290
(0) Comments added on a tracker item are not noticed on tab (color, number, ...)Xavi (as xavidp - admin)210
  • Feature request
amette2005-05-152005-10-060
(0) comments disapper and can't be recoveredMoritz Haag735
  • Error
2005-08-222021-09-301
Bsfez-30 Sep 21
(0) Display external wikis and abbreviations in editormarbux25
  • Usability
marbux2005-11-082021-09-301
Bsfez-30 Sep 21
(0) Wiki syntax doesn't work in Tracker commentsmarbux630
  • Usability
  • Dogfood on a *.tiki.org site
2005-11-122021-09-302
Bsfez-30 Sep 21
(0) voting on forum post comments shown & working when rating per forum not selectedXavi (as xavidp - admin)630
  • Error
Marc Laporte2005-12-072009-04-101
xavidp-05 Jan 07
(0) Last comments for trackers : module neededMarc Laporte525
  • Feature request
  • Dogfood on a *.tiki.org site
Luis Henrique Fagundes2005-06-302007-08-131
fmathias-20 Jan 06
(0) Comments to Image Galleries cause failure in mod-since_last_visit_new.php causing site crash25
  • Error
2006-01-222021-10-052
Bsfez-05 Oct 21
(0) Comments: anonymous editors must input anti-bot code:Marc Laporte525
  • Feature request
sylvieg2006-04-152007-12-256
mrisch-25 Jun 08
(0) Comments to individual files in file galleryMarc Laporte210
  • Feature request
sylvieg2006-05-162021-10-111
Bsfez-11 Oct 21
(0) Only show "10/20/30/All" (drop-down) comments filter if number of comments is > 10Marc Laporte840
  • Usability
  • Feature request
sylvieg2007-01-042007-12-310
(0) Forum & comment threading: make optional and plain (not threaded) by defaultMarc Laporte315
  • Feature request
nyloth2007-05-312021-10-252
Bsfez-25 Oct 21
(0) Comments to individual images in the image galleryMarc Laporte735
  • Feature request
2007-06-022021-10-252
Bsfez-25 Oct 21
(0) Forums: move topic to another forum id (feature already exists)Marc Laporte525
  • Feature request
Mike2007-07-142007-11-290
(0) Better comments featurealain_desilets315
  • Usability
2007-11-012017-06-182
gezza-10 Jan 10
(0) Error in tiki-list_comments.php - no comments on listmrisch525
  • Error
2007-12-312008-01-011
nkoth-01 Jan 08
(0) Comments that must be approved before being postedMarc Laporte525
  • Feature request
nyloth2008-02-212008-10-061
mrisch-04 Jun 08
(0) Comzone cookie not getting updatedspace_egd525
  • Consistency
2008-10-102020-02-261
drsassafras-26 Feb 20
(0) Spam filtering: Bad Behavior or Mollom or Akismet, Defensio or TypePad AntiSpamMarc Laporte840
  • Feature request
  • Dogfood on a *.tiki.org site
2009-04-222011-10-030
(0) thresold...Daniel Germer210
  • Consistency
2005-04-252021-09-231
Bsfez-23 Sep 21

Alias

Comments